Live Feeds
● TRACKER Updated 28d ago · 48 sources tracked

AI training of copyrighted material not fair use: Third Circuit

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on September 29, 2026, ruling that the use of copyrighted material to train artificial intelligence is not protected as fair use. The decision in Thomson Reuters v. Ross Intelligence focused on the unauthorized use of more than 2,000 Westlaw editorial headnote summaries to build a competing legal platform. This ruling establishes that such headnotes contain enough original content to qualify for copyright protection, rejecting the fair use defense for the AI tool.

🎙️

Listen to Live Briefing

Real-time synthesized voice briefing · Live Feeds Desk

⏱ ~3 min
Speed:
RSS Source map (48)
⚡ Key Developments & Real-Time Context
Text size:
  • ✓ The Third Circuit affirmed partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on September 29, 2026.
  • ✓ The ruling held that using copyrighted material to train AI is not fair use in the Thomson Reuters v. Ross case.
  • ✓ The dispute involved the use of over 2,000 Westlaw headnote summaries.
  • ✓ There are currently 144 AI copyright lawsuits, with 113 remaining active.
🛡️ Source Corroboration: 48 independent reporting domains (100% confidence) ⏱ Read time: ~2 min

What changed

The court issued its formal affirmation of partial summary judgment on September 29, 2026, in case No. 25-2153.

Live updates

  1. Third Circuit rules AI training on copyrighted headnotes is not fair use

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on September 29, 2026, ruling that the use of copyrighted material to train artificial intelligence is not protected as fair use. The decision in Thomson Reuters v. Ross Intelligence focused on the unauthorized use of more than 2,000 Westlaw editorial headnote summaries to build a competing legal platform. This ruling establishes that such headnotes contain enough original content to qualify for copyright protection, rejecting the fair use defense for the AI tool.

    Why it matters

    This case tests the legal boundaries of how AI companies acquire training data from proprietary sources. It arrives as AI copyright litigation grows, with total lawsuits reaching 144. The outcome affects whether AI developers must pay for datasets or can rely on fair use exemptions.

    What is confirmed

    • The Third Circuit affirmed partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on September 29, 2026.
    • The ruling held that using copyrighted material to train AI is not fair use in the Thomson Reuters v. Ross case.
    • The dispute involved the use of over 2,000 Westlaw headnote summaries.
    • There are currently 144 AI copyright lawsuits, with 113 remaining active.

    What to watch next

    • Further appeals or a final judgment in the Thomson Reuters v. Ross litigation
    • Rulings in the 113 remaining active AI copyright lawsuits
    Sources used for this update (8)
    1. ailawsuittracker.com — Major AI Court Rulings (2026): Fair Use, Output & More
    2. prospect.org — The Week AI Blinked?
    3. www.licentium.io — Third Circuit Rejects AI Training Fair Use in Thomson Reuters ...
    4. www.schneier.com — Friday Squid Blogging: Squid Before the Chicxulub Meteor Impact - Schneier on Security
    5. aeonlaw.com — Third Circuit Affirms AI Legal Platform Not Covered by “Fair Use”
    6. for.you.com — AI Copyright Lawsuits Hit 144 as Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use
    7. superpowerdaily.com — Music publishers warn Australia against weakening copyright for AI training | Superpower Daily
    8. wattsupwiththat.com — We must embrace AI and data centers, not pause them - Watts Up With That?
    confidence 100%
  2. Third Circuit Rejects AI Fair Use Defense

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled that using copyrighted material to train artificial intelligence is not protected as fair use. The decision, stemming from the Thomson Reuters v. Ross lawsuit, affirmed a grant of partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters. The litigation involved allegations that Ross Intelligence copied Westlaw editorial headnotes to develop a competing legal platform. The appellate court established that these headnotes contain sufficient original content to receive copyright protection.

    Why it matters

    This appellate decision marks a milestone in copyright law as courts grapple with the intersection of artificial intelligence and intellectual property rights. The lawsuit specifically targeted the use of proprietary legal research materials to train a competing search tool. Observers note that the ruling leaves open questions regarding how fair use applies to other AI applications, such as chatbots or image generators.

    What is confirmed

    • The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a grant of partial summary judgment in favor of Thomson Reuters.
    • The appellate court ruled that using copyrighted material to train artificial intelligence is not protected as fair use in this context.
    • The case involves allegations that Ross Intelligence copied Westlaw editorial headnotes to develop a competing legal platform.
    • The court found that Westlaw headnotes contain sufficient original content to receive copyright protection.
    • The federal appeals court ruling did not decide the fair use question for chatbots or image generators, which remains open.

    What to watch next

    • Decisions addressing whether AI training for chatbots and image generators constitutes fair use
    • Further legal proceedings in Thomson Reuters v. Ross regarding remaining claims
    Sources used for this update (6)
    1. en.sedaily.com — NAVER Map Navigation Comes to AI Glasses From Meta, Google, Samsung - Seoul Economic Daily
    2. barrysookman.com — Thomson Reuters v ROSS: What the AI Training Fair Use Ruling ...
    3. natlawreview.com — Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use Defense for AI Training
    4. whyevolutionistrue.com — Saturday: Hili dialogue – Why Evolution Is True
    5. michiganlawreview.org — The Bluebook: An Insider’s Perspective - Michigan Law Review
    6. observed.org — Can AI Companies Train on Copyrighted Work Without Permission?
    confidence 100%
  3. Third Circuit Denies Fair Use for AI Training

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled that using copyrighted material to train artificial intelligence is not protected as fair use. The decision came in Thomson Reuters v. Ross, involving allegations that Ross Intelligence copied Westlaw headnotes to develop a competing legal platform. The appellate court affirmed that Westlaw headnotes contain sufficient original content to receive copyright protection. This marks the first federal appellate decision to address fair use specifically within the context of training artificial intelligence models.

    Why it matters

    The dispute centers on how tech developers source text and data to build software tools. Legal experts view the outcome as a significant signal that developers need formal licenses to utilize protected content. The ruling focuses on a specialized, non-generative legal tool rather than broader generative artificial intelligence systems.

    What is confirmed

    • The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit rejected the argument that using copyrighted material for artificial intelligence training is fair use.
    • The case is Thomson Reuters v. Ross.
    • The Third Circuit upheld the ruling that Thomson Reuters headnotes have enough original content to warrant copyright protection.
    • Headnotes are short descriptions of legal issues that appear before judicial opinions.
    • Ross used a third-party tool to glean information from Westlaw and train its own legal tool.

    What to watch next

    • Whether Ross Intelligence petitions the U.S. Supreme Court to review the Third Circuit decision.
    Sources used for this update (10)
    1. www.law360.com — Intellectual Property : Law360 : Legal News & Analysis
    2. meadowlandsmedia.com — AI Training Not Fair Use of Copyrighted Material, Appeals ...
    3. www.dailykos.com — AI Can’t Tell Real Science From Junk. That’s a Big Problem. - Daily Kos
    4. www.discoveryeducation.com — Our Corporate Partnerships | Discovery Education
    5. www.thenation.com — This November, Vote Like Alito Is on the Ballot | The Nation
    6. file770.com — Pixel Scroll 10/7/26 We’ll Make You Walk The Plonk, But Only If It Tastes Good | File 770
    7. legaltechdigest.com — Third Circuit Rules Against Fair Use for AI Training on ...
    8. floridapolitics.com — Sunburn — The morning read of what’s hot in Florida politics — 10.14.26
    9. www.lawnext.com — 'No More Than an Ordinary Copyright Case' -- 3rd Circuit Unseals Its Opinion In Thomson Reuters Case Against ROSS | LawSites
    10. news.aidocx.ai — Third Circuit Ruling: AI Training Data Is Not Fair Use ...
    confidence 100%
  4. Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use for AI Training

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled that utilizing copyrighted material to train artificial intelligence does not qualify as fair use. The litigation involved ROSS Intelligence using Westlaw summaries to train a competing legal research platform. Industry groups like the AAP and the Authors Guild praised the outcome, while ROSS Intelligence intends to seek an appeal before the Supreme Court. Analysts note the decision focuses on a non-generative legal tool rather than resolving broader generative AI model questions. The Third Circuit also held that Westlaw headnotes are copyrightable.

    Why it matters

    This appellate decision establishes a significant judicial precedent concerning intellectual property rights and artificial intelligence training datasets. The litigation tests how traditional copyright law applies to machine learning models developed by tech startups. Because the ruling originates from the Third Circuit, it directly impacts districts across Delaware, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and the Virgin Islands while drawing intense scrutiny from creative industries nationwide.

    What is confirmed

    • The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a lower court ruling against ROSS Intelligence, determining that utilizing copyrighted material to train artificial intelligence does not constitute fair use.
    • The Third Circuit held that Westlaw headnotes are copyrightable.

    Still unconfirmed

    • ROSS Intelligence intends to seek an appeal before the Supreme Court.

    What to watch next

    • Whether the Supreme Court agrees to hear an appeal from ROSS Intelligence.
    • Further judicial rulings addressing generative AI models specifically.
    Sources used for this update (3)
    1. www.harrisbeachmurtha.com — Copyright, AI Training & Westlaw Headnotes | Harris Beach Murtha
    2. lithub.com — Literary Hub » The Third Circuit finds that AI companies can’t use material with an original “creati....
    3. natlawreview.com — Westlaw Headnotes Meet AI Training: Third Circuit Applies Traditional Fair Use Rules
    confidence 100%
  5. Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use for AI Training Data

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a lower court ruling against ROSS Intelligence, determining that utilizing copyrighted material to train artificial intelligence does not constitute fair use. The litigation involved the defunct startup's use of Westlaw summaries to train a competing legal research platform. Industry groups including the AAP and the Authors Guild applauded the judicial outcome. Meanwhile, ROSS Intelligence intends to seek an appeal before the Supreme Court. Analysts note that the specific decision centers on a non-generative legal tool's handling of copyrighted text rather than settling the broader question of generative AI models.

    Why it matters

    This appellate decision represents the first time a federal appeals court has evaluated and rejected the fair use defense within the context of artificial intelligence training data. The underlying lawsuit centered on Thomson Reuters claiming copyright infringement by ROSS Intelligence. While publishing and author organizations welcomed the strict interpretation of copyright law, the exact boundary for generative AI training models remains unresolved by this narrow ruling.

    What is confirmed

    • The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit rejected the fair use defense for AI training in Thomson Reuters v. ROSS.
    • The appellate panel affirmed the district court ruling against ROSS Intelligence.
    • The dispute involved the use of Westlaw headnotes and summaries to train an AI legal research tool.
    • The AAP and Authors Guild welcomed the court decision.

    Still unconfirmed

    • ROSS Intelligence plans to seek an appeal at the Supreme Court.

    What to watch next

    • Any formal filing for an appeal by ROSS Intelligence to the U.S. Supreme Court.
    • Further judicial clarity on whether training generative AI models qualifies as fair use.
    Sources used for this update (7)
    1. note.com — パテサロデイリー【昨日の英語知財ニュース】 2026年10月4日号|パテントサロ....
    2. c4sif.org — Libertarian and IP Answer Man: Artificial Intelligence and IP
    3. superpowerdaily.com — Appeals Court Upholds Thomson Reuters’ Copyright Win Over AI Training | Superpower Daily
    4. futurism.com — Court Finds That Using Copyrighted Material as AI Training ...
    5. www.musicbusinessworldwide.com — With a new CFO, three licensing deals, and $775M+ raised, what’s stopping $5.4B-valued Suno from an IPO?
    6. note.com — パテサロデイリー【昨日の英語知財ニュース】 2026年10月8日号
    7. natlawreview.com — First Federal Appellate Fair Use Ruling on AI Training Rejects Non-Generative AI’s Use of Copyrighted H....
    confidence 95%
  6. Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use for AI Training on Copyrights

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled on September 29, 2026, that training artificial intelligence systems on copyrighted material does not qualify as fair use. This decision stems from a legal battle between Thomson Reuters and the defunct startup ROSS Intelligence, which used Westlaw headnotes to train an AI legal research tool. The appellate panel affirmed the district court ruling against ROSS. This marks the first time a federal appeals court has evaluated and rejected the fair use defense within the specific context of artificial intelligence training data.

    Why it matters

    Technology companies and copyright holders have watched this long-running litigation closely as a bellwether for generative artificial intelligence development. Because courts have rarely addressed how traditional copyright doctrines apply to machine learning ingestion, this appellate precedent sets a significant marker for future disputes. Legal analysts expect the outcome to reshape how developers source datasets for training language models and specialized software.

    What is confirmed

    • The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit issued the first federal appellate decision addressing copyright fair use in the AI-training context on September 29, 2026.
    • Thomson Reuters and ROSS Intelligence engaged in a long-running legal battle over the use of Westlaw headnotes.
    • ROSS Intelligence used Westlaw headnotes to train an AI-driven legal research tool.

    What to watch next

    • Further petitions for review to the Supreme Court of the United States
    • Subsequent copyright infringement lawsuits citing the Third Circuit precedent
    Sources used for this update (5)
    1. www.jw.com — Training Day: Third Circuit Affirms Westlaw Headnotes Decision in AI Copyright Fair Use Case
    2. learn.microsoft.com — AI learning hub - Start your AI learning journey, and build...
    3. gall.dcinside.com — 로이터 소송, 저작권 있는 자료의 AI 학습은 공정 이용이 아니다 - 일러레 미니 ....
    4. learn.microsoft.com — AI Technology Overview - Azure Architecture Center
    5. support.microsoft.com — What you can do with Microsoft Copilot
    confidence 100%
  7. Third Circuit Rejects AI Fair Use Defense in Thomson Reuters Win

    A United States federal appeals court ruled that training an artificial intelligence system on copyrighted material does not qualify as fair use. The Third Circuit delivered the decision in a copyright lawsuit won by Thomson Reuters against the now-shuttered legal research startup ROSS Intelligence. The appellate panel rejected the fair use defense after ROSS copied Westlaw headnotes to build training data for an artificial intelligence tool designed to answer legal questions. The ruling marks the first time a US appeals court has tested and rejected the fair use defense in the context of artificial intelligence training.

    Why it matters

    The copyright battle centers on how artificial intelligence developers source training data without infringing on protected works. Thomson Reuters accused ROSS Intelligence of misappropriating proprietary legal headnotes from Westlaw to build its competing platform. The outcome delivers a major victory for copyright holders and establishes a significant precedent that could impact other tech companies facing scrutiny over their data collection practices.

    What is confirmed

    • The Third Circuit ruled that training an AI on copyrighted material is not fair use.
    • Thomson Reuters won its copyright lawsuit against the legal research startup ROSS Intelligence.
    • The case involved an AI tool trained on proprietary Westlaw legal headnotes.
    • The decision marks the first time an appellate court has tested the fair use defense for AI training.

    Still unconfirmed

    • The specific legal reasoning detailed within the Third Circuit opinion will heavily influence ongoing copyright disputes involving generative AI models like Suno.

    What to watch next

    • Unsealing and public release of the complete Third Circuit opinion
    • Potential appeals or further legal actions from artificial intelligence companies facing similar copyright challenges
    Sources used for this update (18)
    1. Reuters — US appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters' landmark win in AI training lawsuit
    2. lawnext.com — 3rd Circuit Issues Opinion in Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Case, But For Now It Is Sealed
    3. Copyright Lately — Signed, Sealed, Affirmed: Third Circuit Backs Thomson Reuters over ROSS
    4. Courthouse News — AI training of copyrighted material not fair use: Third Circuit
    5. Forbes — AI Lost Its First Fair Use Appeal. Suno Should Be Worried.
    6. Music Business Worldwide — US appeals court rejects ‘fair use’ defense over AI training – as Thomson Reuters wins copyright case backed by RIAA and NMPA
    7. Nieman Journalism Lab — Federal appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters’ landmark AI copyright win
    8. LawSites — 3rd Circuit Rules For Thomson Reuters In Its Copyright Fight Against Legal Research Startup ROSS
    9. National Review — Copyright Protects Against Training AI on Legal Headnotes
    10. jen.jiji.com — Formula 1, Bahrain GP results and World Championship standings
    11. jen.jiji.com — Florence, the eighth edition of the National Festival of Civil Economy concludes
    12. www.musicbusinessworldwide.com — US appeals court rejects ‘fair use’ defense over AI training – as Thomson Reuters wins copyright ca....
    confidence 100%
📊

Community Sentiment: How do you assess this situation?

Voice your perspective · Real-time aggregated sentiment from the Live Feeds community