Amazon’s Decoy Deals: Groundwork Investigation Reveals Nearly 1 in 3 Black Friday and Cyber Monday “Deals” Advertised by Amazon Offered No Savings to Shoppers, Nearly 1 in 10 Were Actually More Expensive
A Groundwork Collaborative investigation released this week analyzed Amazon's Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotions and concluded that nearly one in three advertised deals provided no actual discount compared to prior prices, while nearly one in ten items were more expensive during the sale event than before it. The watchdog group's findings have been reported by multiple outlets including The Verge, USA Today, MarketWatch, and Common Dreams. Amazon has disputed the study's methodology and conclusions, issuing a statement titled "Correcting the record about Amazon's deal-event pricing" to push back on the characterization of its discounts as deceptive.
Listen to Live Briefing
Real-time synthesized voice briefing · Live Feeds Desk
- ✓ Groundwork Collaborative investigation found nearly one in three Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals offered no savings to shoppers.
- ✓ The same investigation found nearly one in ten Amazon deals were actually more expensive during the sale event.
- ✓ Multiple news outlets including The Verge, USA Today, MarketWatch, and Common Dreams reported on the Groundwork findings.
- ✓ Amazon issued a statement titled "Correcting the record about Amazon's deal-event pricing" disputing the study.
What changed
Groundwork Collaborative published a new investigation quantifying the share of Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals that offered zero or negative savings, prompting widespread coverage and a formal Amazon denial.
Live updates
-
Groundwork investigation finds nearly one-third of Amazon Black Friday deals offered no savings
A Groundwork Collaborative investigation released this week analyzed Amazon's Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotions and concluded that nearly one in three advertised deals provided no actual discount compared to prior prices, while nearly one in ten items were more expensive during the sale event than before it. The watchdog group's findings have been reported by multiple outlets including The Verge, USA Today, MarketWatch, and Common Dreams. Amazon has disputed the study's methodology and conclusions, issuing a statement titled "Correcting the record about Amazon's deal-event pricing" to push back on the characterization of its discounts as deceptive.
Why it matters
The investigation adds to ongoing scrutiny of retail pricing practices during major shopping holidays, where reference prices and limited-time offers can obscure true value for consumers. Groundwork Collaborative, a progressive economic think tank, framed the findings as evidence of "decoy deals" designed to create urgency without delivering savings. Amazon's rebuttal signals the stakes for the platform's credibility with holiday shoppers and regulators alike.
What is confirmed
- Groundwork Collaborative investigation found nearly one in three Amazon Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals offered no savings to shoppers.
- The same investigation found nearly one in ten Amazon deals were actually more expensive during the sale event.
- Multiple news outlets including The Verge, USA Today, MarketWatch, and Common Dreams reported on the Groundwork findings.
- Amazon issued a statement titled "Correcting the record about Amazon's deal-event pricing" disputing the study.
Still unconfirmed
- Ronan Farrow commented on the investigation in a segment for The Verge.
What to watch next
- FTC or state attorney general response to the pricing allegations
- Amazon's detailed methodology rebuttal and any supporting data release
- Consumer advocacy group lawsuits or formal complaints citing the Groundwork study
confidence 90%Sources used for this update (10)
- www.pcmag.com — Everything You Need To Know About Black Friday 2026: The Biggest Sales, the Best Deals, and More
- Groundwork Collaborative — Amazon’s Decoy Deals: Groundwork Investigation Reveals Nearly 1 in 3 Black Friday and Cyber Monday “Deals” Advertised by Amazon Offered No Savings to Shoppers, Nearly 1 in 10 Were Actually More Expensive
- Groundwork Collaborative — Deal or Decoy? Amazon’s Deceptive Discounts
- The Verge — Ronan Farrow on the new investigation into Amazon’s Black Friday deals.
- USA Today — Watchdog says Amazon Black Friday sales aren't real deals
- Common Dreams — ‘Fake Deals, Real Rip-Offs’: 1 in 10 of Amazon's 'Best' Holiday Deals Are Actually More Expensive, Study Finds
- The Verge — Nearly 1 in 3 Amazon Black Friday deals offer no real savings, according to report.
- MarketWatch — Do Amazon’s Black Friday deals really save you money? A new report casts doubt.
- Yahoo — Amazon fires back at study calling its Black Friday deals fake
- www.marketscreener.com — Amazon com : Correcting the record about Amazon’s deal-event pricing
Community Sentiment: How do you assess this situation?
Voice your perspective · Real-time aggregated sentiment from the Live Feeds community