Live Feeds
● TRACKER Updated 27d ago · 28 sources tracked

Britain scraps heavily criticised plans to curb jury trials after backlash

Prime Minister Andy Burnham's administration abandoned plans for judge-only trials in Crown Court cases carrying sentences of three years or less, aiming to address a backlog of nearly 81,000 cases awaiting jury trial as of June. Despite this retreat, the Courts and Tribunals Bill now heading to the House of Lords still contains contentious measures that remove defendants' rights to elect jury trials. Critics and groups like the Free Speech Union argue that scaling back these specific proposals fails to restore broader jury trial rights or properly resolve the backlog.

🎙️

Listen to Live Briefing

Real-time synthesized voice briefing · Live Feeds Desk

⏱ ~3 min
Speed:
RSS Source map (28)
⚡ Key Developments & Real-Time Context
Text size:
  • ✓ Prime Minister Andy Burnham's administration decided to scrap plans for judge-only trials in Crown Court cases with sentences of three years or less on 13 October 2026.
  • ✓ The backlog of cases awaiting jury trial stood at nearly 81,000 as of June.
  • ✓ The Courts and Tribunals Bill has passed a key stage and now sits with the House of Lords.
🛡️ Source Corroboration: 28 independent reporting domains (100% confidence) ⏱ Read time: ~3 min

What changed

The government abandoned its controversial plans for judge-only Crown Court trials while continuing to advance the Courts and Tribunals Bill through parliament.

Live updates

  1. UK Government Retreats on Judge-Only Trials as Legal Battles Loom

    Prime Minister Andy Burnham's administration abandoned plans for judge-only trials in Crown Court cases carrying sentences of three years or less, aiming to address a backlog of nearly 81,000 cases awaiting jury trial as of June. Despite this retreat, the Courts and Tribunals Bill now heading to the House of Lords still contains contentious measures that remove defendants' rights to elect jury trials. Critics and groups like the Free Speech Union argue that scaling back these specific proposals fails to restore broader jury trial rights or properly resolve the backlog.

    Why it matters

    The legislation has drawn fierce backlash from legal commentators and campaign groups who view the ongoing legislative package as a threat to ancient jury rights. While the government withdrew its specific proposal for judge-only trials on 13 October 2026, shadow justice minister Kieran Mullan contends that the remaining flaws in the bill still require significant challenge.

    What is confirmed

    • Prime Minister Andy Burnham's administration decided to scrap plans for judge-only trials in Crown Court cases with sentences of three years or less on 13 October 2026.
    • The backlog of cases awaiting jury trial stood at nearly 81,000 as of June.
    • The Courts and Tribunals Bill has passed a key stage and now sits with the House of Lords.

    Still unconfirmed

    • Scaling back proposals to eliminate judge-only trials does not mean restoring the jury trial rights that the remaining reforms in the bill would remove.
    • The Free Speech Union delivered a petition to Downing Street to save jury trials after arguing that the reforms would barely dent the court backlog.
    • Judges in England and Wales will be able to keep inmates in cells longer or stop visits if criminals refuse to attend sentencing.

    What to watch next

    • Amendments made to the Courts and Tribunals Bill during its passage through the House of Lords.
    • Further responses from the Free Speech Union and legal organizations regarding the remaining jury trial restrictions.
    Sources used for this update (4)
    1. www.lawgazette.co.uk — Questions remain over government’s jury trial retreat
    2. www.newlawjournal.co.uk — NLJ this week: Jury battle looms | New Law Journal | The ...
    3. freespeechunion.org — The Free Speech Union heads to Downing Street to save jury ...
    4. www.theguardian.com — Criminals who refuse to attend sentencing face losing prison ...
    confidence 100%
  2. Courts and Tribunals Bill moves to House of Lords after jury trial reversal

    The Courts and Tribunals Bill has passed a key stage and now sits with the House of Lords. The legislation follows the decision by Prime Minister Andy Burnham's administration on 13 October 2026 to scrap plans for judge-only trials in Crown Court cases with sentences of three years or less. While the government intends to reduce a backlog of nearly 81,000 cases awaiting jury trial as of June, shadow justice minister Kieran Mullan argues that removing the judge-only trial element does not fix the remaining flaws in the legislative package.

    Why it matters

    The government originally sought to accelerate court proceedings by removing juries from lower-sentence cases. This move faced significant backlash from legal experts and political opponents. The bill now aims to address systemic delays in England and Wales.

    What is confirmed

    • The government abandoned plans for judge-only trials in Crown Court cases likely to receive a sentence of three years or less during the Commons Report Stage on 13 October 2026.
    • Crown Courts in England and Wales had nearly 81,000 cases awaiting jury trial as of June.
    • The Courts and Tribunals Bill is now in the hands of the House of Lords.

    Still unconfirmed

    • Shadow justice minister Kieran Mullan claims the remaining elements of the Courts and Tribunals Bill are not good law.
    • Legal experts warn that jury trials remain under threat through alternative measures.

    What to watch next

    • House of Lords amendments or approval of the Courts and Tribunals Bill
    • Official updates on Crown Court backlog figures following the reversal
    Sources used for this update (5)
    1. www.irishtimes.com — Andy Burnham - The Irish Times
    2. www.lawgazette.co.uk — Revamped Courts and Tribunals Bill passes crucial hurdle
    3. www.lawgazette.co.uk — Joshua Rozenberg: Jury still out on Courts and Tribunals Bill ...
    4. www.thetimes.com.au — Can juries still deliver justice in high-profile cases in the ...
    5. metro.co.uk — Amy Dowden responds to Strictly pro’s vicious criticism of ...
    confidence 100%
  3. UK Government Drops Judge-Only Trial Plans

    Prime Minister Andy Burnham's administration has dropped controversial plans for judge-only trials in Crown Court cases likely to receive a sentence of three years or less. The government abandoned the measure during the Commons Report Stage of the Courts and Tribunals Bill on 13 October 2026. Crown Courts across England and Wales faced nearly 81,000 cases awaiting jury trial as of June. Officials maintain that court backlogs will still fall despite the reversal. However, legal experts warn that jury trials remain under threat through alternative measures.

    Why it matters

    Keir Starmer originally proposed the measures to combat mounting pressure on the legal system. The reversal follows heavy backlash from members of Parliament, legal professionals, and the public. Despite the retreat on judge-only formats, the Ministry of Justice is piloting virtual courts in London and Sheffield to ease pressure.

    What is confirmed

    • The Government dropped its proposal for judge-only trials in Crown Court cases likely to receive a sentence of three years or less during the Commons Report Stage of the Courts and Tribunals Bill on 13th October 2026.
    • The Courts and Tribunals Bill passed its Third Reading by 301 votes to 193.
    • Crown Courts across England and Wales faced nearly 81,000 cases awaiting jury trial as of June.
    • The Ministry of Justice is piloting virtual courts in London and Sheffield.

    Still unconfirmed

    • Legal reform advocates warn that the government still intends to cut thousands of jury trials by the back door via the magistrates' courts, and significant concerns remain about plans to restrict access to jury trials.

    What to watch next

    • Progression of the Courts and Tribunals Bill through Parliament after its Third Reading.
    • Results and rollout updates from the Ministry of Justice virtual court pilots in London and Sheffield.
    • Further government action regarding magistrates' sentencing powers and access to jury trials.
    Sources used for this update (6)
    1. www.endthefear.co.uk — News – Government steps back from judge-only trials but must ...
    2. www.theguardian.com — Why plan for judge-only trials in fraud cases is wrong
    3. www.lawgazette.co.uk — In depth: Jury trials back in the crosshairs | Law Gazette
    4. www.scottishlegal.com — England: MoJ trials virtual courts as jury trial reforms face ...
    5. www.lbc.co.uk — Jury trials are still under threat - no matter what Andy ...
    6. www.sahotasahota.co.uk — Government drops wider plan for judge-only Crown Court trials
    confidence 95%
  4. UK Government Abandons Plans to Restrict Jury Trials

    Prime Minister Andy Burnham has abandoned controversial plans to strip defendants of the right to trial by jury in less serious criminal cases. The reversal follows months of heavy backlash from members of Parliament, legal professionals, and the public. Keir Starmer originally proposed the measures to combat mounting pressure on the legal system. Although officials have axed the policy, they maintain that court backlogs will still fall. Crown Courts across England and Wales faced nearly 81,000 cases awaiting jury trial as of June.

    Why it matters

    The scrapped proposals originated during the tenure of Keir Starmer to address administrative strain in the justice system. Ministers had floated the curb as a method to clear systemic blockages, drawing sharp criticism from legal defenders and politicians who viewed the move as an attack on historic rights. The sudden retreat highlights the political cost of altering fundamental judicial procedures.

    What is confirmed

    • Prime Minister Andy Burnham has abandoned controversial plans to curb jury trials.
    • The proposals were originally introduced under Keir Starmer to address court backlogs.
    • The reversal follows intense pushback and outcry from lawyers, politicians, and the public.
    • Crown Courts across England and Wales had nearly 81,000 cases awaiting trial by jury as of June.
    • Ministers maintain that court backlogs will still fall despite the policy U-turn.

    What to watch next

    • Alternative government strategies to address the nearly 81,000 cases awaiting trial in Crown Courts
    • Official government reports detailing how court backlogs will fall without jury trial restrictions
    Sources used for this update (6)
    1. www.globalbankingandfinance.com — Manchester City Beat Arsenal 4-2 to Stay Top in Women's Super League
    2. www.globalbankingandfinance.com — Russia Set to Intensify Strikes on Ukraine After Zelenskiy Response
    3. www.legalcheek.com — Jury trial curbs scaled back in government u-turn - Legal Cheek
    4. novaramedia.com — Burnham Scraps Starmer-Era Plans to Roll Back Jury Trials
    5. www.europesays.com — UK PM Andy Burnham scraps Starmer-era plans to curb jury ...
    6. uk.news.yahoo.com — Courts backlog will fall despite axing plan to curb jury ...
    confidence 100%
  5. UK Government Drops Controversial Plans to Curb Jury Trials

    Prime Minister Andy Burnham has abandoned controversial government plans to strip defendants of the historic right to trial by jury in less serious criminal cases. Announced on Sunday, the reversal follows fierce backlash from lawyers and politicians who criticized the proposed justice reforms. Ministers originally floated the curb to address mounting pressure on the legal system, which included nearly 81,000 cases awaiting trial by jury in Crown Courts across England and Wales as of June. Despite the policy U-turn, officials maintain that court backlogs will still fall.

    Why it matters

    The dropped policy was a holdover from the administration of Keir Starmer before Burnham assumed the role of prime minister in July. The legal system has faced severe strains, illustrated by prisoners being released early to prevent overcrowded jails amid a wider criminal justice crisis. Scrapping the jury trial restrictions preserves a foundational element of the British criminal justice system.

    What is confirmed

    • Prime Minister Andy Burnham announced on Sunday that Britain will scrap plans to remove the right to trial by jury for defendants in less serious criminal cases.
    • The case backlog awaiting trial by jury in Crown Courts in England and Wales reached nearly 81,000 in June.
    • Andy Burnham became prime minister in July, succeeding Keir Starmer.
    • Alex Norris stated that court backlogs will still fall despite the jury trials U-turn.

    What to watch next

    • Further government announcements on how ministers intend to reduce Crown Court backlogs without restricting jury trials.
    Sources used for this update (15)
    1. reuters.com — Britain scraps heavily criticised plans to curb jury trials after backlash
    2. theguardian.com — Ministers drop plans to cut jury trials in England and Wales after outcry
    3. BBC — Burnham scraps controversial plans to curb jury trials
    4. Bloomberg.com — UK Government to ‘Change Course’ on Plan to Curb Jury Trials
    5. Financial Times — Andy Burnham reverses much of plan to scrap jury trials
    6. The Independent — Court backlogs will still fall despite jury trials U-turn, Alex Norris says
    7. The Independent — Burnham scraps controversial Starmer plan to axe jury trials
    8. www.irishtimes.com — Britain scraps heavily criticised plans to curb jury trials after backlash – The Irish Times
    9. www.cnbctv18.com — Britain scraps heavily criticised plans to curb jury trials after backlash - CNBC TV18
    10. www.globalbankingandfinance.com — Britain scraps heavily criticised plans to curb jury trials after
    11. srnnews.com — Britain scraps heavily criticised plans to curb jury trials after backlash - SRN News
    12. www.straitstimes.com — Britain scraps plans to curb jury trials after backlash
    confidence 100%
📊

Community Sentiment: How do you assess this situation?

Voice your perspective · Real-time aggregated sentiment from the Live Feeds community