Live Feeds
● TRACKER Updated 23d ago · 41 sources tracked

US appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters' landmark win in AI training lawsuit

The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upheld Thomson Reuters' copyright victory against ROSS Intelligence, rejecting the fair-use defense for using Westlaw material to train an AI search engine. This ruling affirms a February 2025 decision by Delaware Judge Stephanos Bibas and marks the first federal appellate decision to reject fair use claims regarding publisher data for AI training. ROSS Intelligence, which used a third-party tool to extract editorial headnotes for a rival product, is now defunct.

🎙️

Listen to Live Briefing

Real-time synthesized voice briefing · Live Feeds Desk

⏱ ~3 min
Speed:
RSS Source map (41)
⚡ Key Developments & Real-Time Context
Text size:
  • ✓ The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on September 29, 2026.
  • ✓ The court rejected the argument that training a legal AI platform on scraped Westlaw data constitutes fair use.
  • ✓ ROSS Intelligence, the startup that used a third-party tool to extract editorial headnotes for a rival product, is now defunct.
  • ✓ This is the first federal appellate decision to reject fair use claims regarding the use of publisher data for AI training.
🛡️ Source Corroboration: 41 independent reporting domains (100% confidence) ⏱ Read time: ~2 min

What changed

The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed the partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on September 29, 2026, upholding the February 2025 decision by Delaware Judge Stephanos Bibas.

Live updates

  1. US appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters' AI training lawsuit win

    The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upheld Thomson Reuters' copyright victory against ROSS Intelligence, rejecting the fair-use defense for using Westlaw material to train an AI search engine. This ruling affirms a February 2025 decision by Delaware Judge Stephanos Bibas and marks the first federal appellate decision to reject fair use claims regarding publisher data for AI training. ROSS Intelligence, which used a third-party tool to extract editorial headnotes for a rival product, is now defunct.

    Why it matters

    This case has significant implications for AI firms and the use of proprietary data for training their systems. The ruling may require AI companies to pay more for the data they use, potentially impacting the availability of high-quality proprietary data. The decision also sets a precedent for the use of publisher data in AI training, which could affect the development of AI technology in various industries.

    What is confirmed

    • The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on September 29, 2026.
    • The court rejected the argument that training a legal AI platform on scraped Westlaw data constitutes fair use.
    • ROSS Intelligence, the startup that used a third-party tool to extract editorial headnotes for a rival product, is now defunct.
    • This is the first federal appellate decision to reject fair use claims regarding the use of publisher data for AI training.

    What to watch next

    • The potential impact of this ruling on AI firms and the use of proprietary data for training their systems
    • The development of AI technology in various industries and potential future lawsuits
    • The availability of high-quality proprietary data for AI training
    Sources used for this update (4)
    1. help.naver.com — Futures Flat As Oil Rebounds After Trump's "Energy Ceasefire" Unravels, Memory Stocks Slide | ZeroHedge
    2. agihunt.info — Appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters win: AI… · AGI Hunt
    3. article.wn.com — US appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters win in landmark AI ...
    4. for.you.com — AI Fair Use Rejected on Appeal as Chatbot Liability Rulings Mount
    confidence 100%
  2. Third Circuit upholds Thomson Reuters copyright win against Ross Intelligence

    The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on 29 September 2026. The court rejected the argument that training a legal AI platform on scraped Westlaw data constitutes fair use. This ruling upholds a February 2025 decision by Delaware Judge Stephanos Bibas. Ross Intelligence, the startup that used a third-party tool to extract editorial headnotes for a rival product, is now defunct. This is the first federal appellate decision to reject fair use claims regarding the use of publisher data for AI training.

    Why it matters

    The dispute centers on whether Westlaw editorial headnotes contain enough original content to merit copyright protection. By ruling against Ross Intelligence, the court limits the ability of AI developers to use proprietary datasets without permission. This sets a precedent for how copyright law applies to the ingestion of data for machine learning.

    What is confirmed

    • The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on 29 September 2026 in case No. 25-2153.
    • Judge Stephanos Bibas of the US District Court of Delaware originally ruled against Ross Intelligence in February 2025.
    • Ross Intelligence is now a defunct legal AI startup.
    • The ruling marks the first time a federal appeals case has rejected a fair use argument for using publisher data to train AI.

    Still unconfirmed

    • The appeals court decision remains sealed.

    What to watch next

    • Release of the full sealed court opinion
    • Further appellate challenges or Supreme Court petitions regarding AI fair use
    Sources used for this update (5)
    1. timesofindia.indiatimes.com — WORLD NEWS
    2. www.theverge.com — Appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters win in AI training ...
    3. www.ai-ap.com — AI-AP | Pro Photo Daily - Around the Net » Legal Brief ...
    4. www.licentium.io — Third Circuit Rejects AI Training Fair Use in Thomson Reuters ...
    5. www.lawfuel.com — How Thomson Reuters’ Win Redefines Fair Use for Legal Tech
    confidence 100%
  3. US Appeals Court Rejects Fair Use Defense in Thomson Reuters AI Case

    The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed a partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters, ruling that training a competing AI platform using Westlaw editorial headnotes is not fair use. This decision establishes that these headnotes contain enough original content to merit copyright protection. Ross Intelligence had utilized a third-party tool to extract this data from Westlaw to develop a rival legal research product. The ruling serves as the first federal appellate decision to address the application of copyright fair use specifically within AI training processes.

    Why it matters

    Legal AI companies often rely on massive datasets of curated legal analysis to train large language models. This case tests whether the transformative nature of AI training overrides the copyright of the original data curator. The outcome creates a legal precedent for how other intellectual property holders may protect their proprietary data from AI scrapers.

    What is confirmed

    • The US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled that using Westlaw headnotes to train a competing AI legal research platform does not qualify as fair use.
    • The court affirmed that Thomson Reuters headnotes possess sufficient original content for copyright protection.
    • Ross Intelligence used a third-party tool to extract data from Westlaw to build a rival legal tool.

    What to watch next

    • Further appeals to the US Supreme Court
    • Final damages assessments for Ross Intelligence
    • Similar rulings in other federal circuits regarding AI training data
    Sources used for this update (3)
    1. en.sedaily.com — NAVER Map Navigation Comes to AI Glasses From Meta, Google, Samsung - Seoul Economic Daily
    2. barrysookman.com — Thomson Reuters v ROSS: What the AI Training Fair Use Ruling ...
    3. natlawreview.com — Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use Defense for AI Training
    confidence 100%
  4. Third Circuit Rejects AI Fair Use in Thomson Reuters v. ROSS

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled that using copyrighted Westlaw headnotes to train a competing artificial intelligence legal research platform does not qualify as fair use. The decision marks the first federal appellate ruling addressing copyright fair use within the artificial intelligence training context. Ross Intelligence used a third-party tool to extract data from the Reuters-owned Westlaw platform to build its own rival legal tool. The appellate court upheld the finding that Thomson Reuters headnotes possess sufficient original content to receive copyright protection.

    Why it matters

    Headnotes serve as brief summaries of legal issues appearing before judicial opinions. The litigation specifically centers on allegations that Ross Intelligence copied Westlaw summaries to construct its product. The Third Circuit backed Westlaw headnotes against Ross in the copyright infringement case.

    What is confirmed

    • The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit rejected the argument that using copyrighted material for AI training purposes constitutes fair use.
    • In Thomson Reuters v. Ross, the court ruled in favor of Thomson Reuters in a copyright infringement case against Ross Intelligence.
    • The Third Circuit upheld the ruling that Thomson Reuters headnotes contain enough original content to warrant copyright protection.
    • Ross Intelligence used a third-party tool to glean information from the Westlaw legal research platform to train its own similar legal tool.

    Still unconfirmed

    • A separate lawsuit targets the Casetext deal by describing it as a killer acquisition days after the Third Circuit ruling.

    What to watch next

    • Further developments in the Casetext antitrust lawsuit
    • Additional legal challenges regarding AI training and copyright fair use defenses
    Sources used for this update (4)
    1. www.lawfuel.com — Thomson Reuters: ROSS Win, Casetext Antitrust Suit Explained
    2. www.bakerdonelson.com — Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use for AI Trained on Westlaw ...
    3. meadowlandsmedia.com — AI Training Not Fair Use of Copyrighted Material, Appeals ...
    4. practus.com — Reuters v. ROSS: Third Circuit Rejects AI Fair Use Defense ...
    confidence 100%
  5. Third Circuit Rejects Fair Use in Thomson Reuters v. ROSS

    The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled on September 29, 2026, that startup ROSS Intelligence infringed Thomson Reuters copyrights. The court found that training a competing AI legal research tool using Westlaw headnotes does not qualify as fair use. This decision marks the first federal appellate ruling directly addressing copyright fair use within the artificial intelligence training context. The litigation involved allegations that ROSS copied Westlaw summaries to build its own product.

    Why it matters

    The long-running legal battle between Thomson Reuters and the now-defunct ROSS Intelligence centers on the boundaries of copyright protection when developing automated tools. While the ruling addresses non-generative artificial intelligence, legal experts note the opinion does not definitively settle whether training generative models constitutes fair use. The Third Circuit determined that ROSS used the copyrighted text to create a direct market competitor rather than a transformative product.

    What is confirmed

    • The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit issued the decision on September 29, 2026.
    • The court affirmed that ROSS Intelligence infringed Thomson Reuters copyrights by using Westlaw headnotes to train an AI legal research tool.
    • The Third Circuit rejected the fair use defense in the first federal appellate ruling of its kind.

    Still unconfirmed

    • Anthropic faces cross-motions on fair use in an ongoing lyrics case while the Kadrey appeal was denied.

    What to watch next

    • Further judicial decisions addressing whether generative artificial intelligence training qualifies as fair use.
    • Developments in other pending copyright lawsuits tracked across the legal industry.
    Sources used for this update (10)
    1. www.jw.com — Training Day: Third Circuit Affirms Westlaw Headnotes Decision in AI Copyright Fair Use Case
    2. axis-intelligence.com — AI Copyright Lawsuits Tracker 2026: Live Case Status
    3. superpowerdaily.com — Appeals Court Upholds Thomson Reuters’ Copyright Win Over AI Training | Superpower Daily
    4. futurism.com — Court Finds That Using Copyrighted Material as AI Training ...
    5. www.musicbusinessworldwide.com — A US appeals court has rejected a ‘fair use’ defense over AI ...
    6. en.ai-creators.tech — Thomson Reuters v. ROSS: Appeals Court Rejects AI Fair Use
    7. s-horowitz.com — Thomson Reuters v. Ross: AI training and Copyright
    8. advertisinglaw.foxrothschild.com — Easy Isn’t Fair: The Third Circuit Explains Why Copying ...
    9. natlawreview.com — First Federal Appellate Fair Use Ruling on AI Training Rejects Non-Generative AI’s Use of Copyrighted H....
    10. letsdatascience.com — Third Circuit Rejects ROSS AI Training Fair Use
    confidence 100%
  6. Third Circuit rejects Ross Intelligence fair use defense in AI copyright case

    The Third Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed on September 29, 2026, that Ross Intelligence infringed Thomson Reuters' copyright by using Westlaw headnotes to train a competing AI legal-research tool. The court rejected the fair use defense, establishing that training an AI on a competitor's proprietary data to create a rival product does not qualify as fair use. This ruling marks the first U.S. appellate decision specifically addressing the intersection of AI training and copyright law.

    Why it matters

    The dispute centers on whether AI companies can scrape copyrighted data to build commercial tools without permission. While general-purpose models may still be protected, this ruling creates a distinction for tools designed to compete directly with the data source. Ross Intelligence is now expected to seek review from the Supreme Court.

    What is confirmed

    • The Third Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed on September 29, 2026, that Ross Intelligence infringed Thomson Reuters' copyrighted Westlaw headnotes.
    • The court rejected the fair use defense for AI training in this case.
    • This is the first U.S. appellate ruling on AI training and fair use.

    Still unconfirmed

    • Training a general-purpose AI model probably still qualifies as fair use.
    • Ross Intelligence plans to pursue an appeal to the Supreme Court.

    What to watch next

    • Supreme Court decision on whether to hear the appeal from Ross Intelligence
    • Future appellate rulings on general-purpose AI models versus competitor-specific tools
    Sources used for this update (4)
    1. www.techtimes.com — AI Training Fair Use Loses First Appellate Test; Generative AI Gets Explicit Carve-Out - Tech Times
    2. mediacopilot.ai — Appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters AI copyright win
    3. legallayer.substack.com — What does Thomson Reuters' landmark AI copyright win tell us ...
    4. journalismcentral.com — Appeals Court Hands AI Industry a Landmark Loss, Siding With ...
    confidence 100%
  7. Appeals Court Backs Thomson Reuters in AI Training Copyright Suit

    The Third Circuit Court of Appeals has rejected fair use defenses in the copyright dispute between Thomson Reuters and legal research rival Ross Intelligence, marking a landmark appellate ruling on artificial intelligence training standards. Copyright organizations including the AAP and Authors Guild praised the judicial outcome. Meanwhile, Ross Intelligence indicated plans to pursue an appeal to the Supreme Court. The Philadelphia-based federal appeals court affirmed the decision protecting copyrighted Westlaw headnotes from unauthorized AI model training uses. Legal experts are closely monitoring the ongoing litigation for broader impacts on intellectual property rights.

    Why it matters

    The litigation centers on whether scraping and utilizing copyrighted Westlaw headnotes to train an artificial intelligence-powered legal search engine falls under fair use protections. This dispute represents the first US appellate decision addressing how copyright law applies to machine learning development. The ongoing appeals process will determine future boundaries for data usage in technology sectors.

    What is confirmed

    • The Third Circuit Court of Appeals rejected fair use defenses in Thomson Reuters versus Ross Intelligence regarding artificial intelligence training.
    • Ross Intelligence plans to seek an appeal before the Supreme Court.
    • The AAP and Authors Guild welcomed the judicial decision.

    What to watch next

    • Whether the Supreme Court agrees to hear the appeal from Ross Intelligence
    • Potential adjustments to artificial intelligence training data practices across the technology sector
    Sources used for this update (3)
    1. www.seroundtable.com — Daily Search Forum Recap: September 30, 2026
    2. www.plagiarismtoday.com — 3 Count: Lego Jacket - Plagiarism Today
    3. note.com — パテサロデイリー【昨日の英語知財ニュース】 2026年10月4日号|パテントサロ....
    confidence 100%
  8. Appeals Court Backs Thomson Reuters in AI Training Copyright Suit

    A US appeals court upheld a ruling for information services company Thomson Reuters on Tuesday in its copyright dispute with former legal research rival Ross Intelligence. The Philadelphia-based Third Circuit Court of Appeals backed Thomson Reuters in the landmark litigation concerning Ross's alleged misuse of copyrighted material, specifically Westlaw headnotes, to train an artificial intelligence-powered legal search engine. The case marks the first US appellate finding addressing fair use standards for artificial intelligence training, delivering a significant victory to copyright holders.

    Why it matters

    The litigation centers on how artificial intelligence companies utilize copyrighted works to train competitive products. The Third Circuit opinion maintains the win for Westlaw regarding the use of headnotes to train an artificial intelligence competitor.

    What is confirmed

    • A US appeals court on Tuesday upheld a ruling for information services company Thomson Reuters in its copyright dispute with former legal-research rival Ross Intelligence.
    • The dispute centers on Ross's alleged misuse of copyrighted material to train an AI-powered legal search engine.
    • The Philadelphia-based 3rd US Circuit Court of Appeals issued the opinion.

    Still unconfirmed

    • The 3rd Circuit opinion was initially sealed before being released.

    What to watch next

    • Further public availability or redaction details of the sealed 3rd Circuit opinion documents.
    • Potential subsequent legal appeals or further proceedings in the Thomson Reuters versus ROSS case.
    Sources used for this update (10)
    1. Reuters — US appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters' landmark win in AI training lawsuit
    2. lawnext.com — 3rd Circuit Issues Opinion in Thomson Reuters v. ROSS Case, But For Now It Is Sealed
    3. Copyright Lately — Signed, Sealed, Affirmed: Third Circuit Backs Thomson Reuters over ROSS
    4. Bloomberg Law News — Westlaw Retains Win Over Use of Headnotes to Train AI Competitor
    5. MLex — First US appellate finding on fair use for AI training favors copyright holders
    6. www.channelnewsasia.com — US appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters' landmark win in AI training lawsuit
    7. www.claimsjournal.com — Appeals Court Upholds Thomson Reuters’ Landmark Win in AI Training Lawsuit - Claims Journal
    8. www.aol.com — US appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters' landmark win in AI training lawsuit - AOL
    9. www.thestar.com.my — US appeals court upholds Thomson Reuters' landmark win in AI training lawsuit
    10. note.com — パテサロデイリー【昨日の英語知財ニュース】 2026年10月2日号|パテントサロ....
    confidence 100%
📊

Community Sentiment: How do you assess this situation?

Voice your perspective · Real-time aggregated sentiment from the Live Feeds community