Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.

Eurozone Rate Setters Face Greater Uncertainty Than in Early Pandemic

A leading central banker in Ireland has issued a stark warning about the unpredictability facing monetary policymakers in the Eurozone. Gabriel Makhlouf, the country’s top financial official, has expressed more concern now than during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. He attributes this heightened uncertainty to the uncertain policies of incoming US president, Donald Trump.

Trump’s Tariffs Pose a Threat to Global Trade

President-elect Donald Trump has announced ambitious plans to introduce hefty import taxes, with potential levies of up to 20% on all US imports, and a potential increase to 60% for goods from China. These unprecedented tariffs have left economists and policymakers on edge. According to the European Central Bank and other economic analysts, such aggressive measures could catalyze a global trade war, significantly denting the growth of the export-dependent Eurozone.

ECB’s Precautionary Measures Are Questioned

Given the perceived risk, some economists have suggested that the ECB should proactively reduce interest rates to safeguard against the negative impacts of Trump’s second term. The Eurozone has seen a weaker-than-expected growth rate, and inflation is falling more rapidly than anticipated, falling short of the ECB’s 2% target. However, Makhlouf, who holds a voting position on the ECB’s governing council, is cautious about such preemptive measures.

Makhlouf’s Concerns About Preemptive Cuts

Makhlouf argues that preemptive rate cuts may not offer the intended insurance against economic disruption. He worries that these moves might create additional problems, such as inflating asset bubbles or complicating the ECB’s objective of maintaining price stability.

“There are so many caveats and so many variables that any scenario analysis risks giving people a wrong sense [that] we understand how all this is going to pan out.” – Gabriel Makhlouf, Irish Central Banker

He advises caution, pointing to the unpredictability of Trump’s administration. Makhlouf acknowledges that while additional trade barriers are unlikely to be beneficial, the exact repercussions for Eurozone growth and inflation are unclear due to numerous economic variables at play.

ECB’s Vigilant Approach and Strategic Rate Decisions

Makhlouf emphasizes the need for vigilance from the ECB. He rejects calls for large, 50-basis-point reductions in interest rates at upcoming meetings in early 2025. In December, the ECB reduced borrowing costs for the fourth time this year by a quarter point. While President Christine Lagarde signaled likely further rate cuts in 2021, she acknowledged that internal council members favored larger reductions in December.

Makhlouf advocates for a measured approach, preferring gradual rate changes unless compelling evidence warrants drastic action. “We haven’t declared victory over inflation yet,” he cautions, citing ongoing concerns about service sector price pressures.

Belief in a Neutral Interest Rate

Makhlouf foresees a future where Eurozone interest rates reach a “neutral” level, neither restricting nor stimulating economic activity. While he cannot specify this exact rate, he dismisses market consensus tying the neutral rate below 2% as premature. This stance reflects a cautious approach to monetary policy amidst profound economic upheaval.

“People who are saying that [the neutral rate is] below 2 are probably ahead of themselves.” – Gabriel Makhlouf, Irish Central Banker

Conclusion

The economic landscape is fraught with uncertainty, driven largely by the volatile policies of the new US administration. Central bankers like Gabriel Makhlouf must navigate this terrain carefully, balancing the risks of trade wars with the need to maintain key economic indicators like inflation and growth. The Eurozone’s monetary policy actions will be crucial in shaping its economic future.

We encourage you to share your thoughts on this topic. What do you think the ECB should do in the face of this uncertainty? Join the discussion below, and subscribe to our newsletter to receive similar insights delivered straight to your inbox.